The flashing green and orange LEDs on the NIC indicate connection issues. The technician should first check for loose connections, pinched bends, and physical damage, which are the most common causes of connection problems. References: CompTIA A+ Certification Exam Guide, Ninth Edition, Chapter 14
The symptoms—flashing green and orange LEDs on the workstation’s NIC—suggest a connectivity issue. In networking troubleshooting, flashing LEDs typically indicate activity (green for link/activity, orange for speed or errors, depending on the NIC), but the combination and context imply an unstable or degraded connection. The cable length of 275ft (84m) is within the maximum distance for Cat 5 UTP (100 meters or 328 feet), so length alone isn’t the immediate problem. However, physical issues like loose connections, pinched bends, or damage could degrade signal quality, causing intermittent or erroneous data transmission.
The CompTIA A+ Core 1 Study Guide emphasizes a systematic troubleshooting approach, starting with the simplest and most common causes before escalating to more complex solutions. Checking the cable’s physical integrity—ensuring proper termination, no sharp bends, and no cuts or interference—is a fundamental first step in network troubleshooting. This aligns with Objective 5.5 ("Given a scenario, troubleshoot problems related to motherboards, RAM, CPU, and power") and Objective 5.2 ("Given a scenario, troubleshoot and diagnose problems with storage drives and RAID arrays"), which extend to networking in practice.
Option A (Check for loose connections, pinched bends, and physical damage): This is the least invasive, most immediate step to rule out common cabling issues, as recommended by CompTIA’s methodology.
Option B (Install a powered hub halfway): Adding a hub or repeater could extend signal strength, but the length is within spec, and this assumes a distance issue without evidence. It’s not the first step.
Option C (Replace with Cat 5 STP): Shielded twisted pair reduces interference, but there’s no indication of EMI yet, and replacing the cable is premature without basic checks.
Option D (Upgrade to multimode fiber): Fiber eliminates distance and interference issues but is a costly, last-resort solution, not a first step.
The study guide prioritizes physical inspection and basic diagnostics before hardware replacements or upgrades, making Option A the correct initial action.
Exact Extracts from the Study Guide:
From The Official CompTIA A+ Core 1 Study Guide (220-1101):
Section 2.6, Networking Hardware:
"Twisted Pair Cabling: The maximum length of a twisted pair cable run (such as Cat 5, Cat 5e, or Cat 6) is 100 meters (328 feet). This includes both patch cables and the main run. Beyond this length, signal degradation (attenuation) becomes significant, and a repeater or switch is needed to boost the signal."
Implication: At 275ft (84m), the cable is within spec, so length isn’t the primary concern.
Section 5.4, Troubleshooting Wired and Wireless Network Problems:
"No connectivity or intermittent connectivity—Check the following: Ensure that all cables are securely connected at both ends (NIC and switch or wall jack). Inspect the cable for damage, such as cuts, crimps, or excessive bending, which can disrupt signal integrity… Verify that the cable length does not exceed the maximum specification for the cable type (e.g., 100 meters for twisted pair)."
"LED indicators—Most NICs and switches have LED indicators to show link status and activity. A solid green light typically indicates a good connection, while flashing may indicate activity. Amber or orange lights can indicate speed (e.g., 10/100 Mbps vs. 1 Gbps) or errors, depending on the device."
Section 5.4, Troubleshooting Methodology:
"Identify the problem… Gather information… Establish a theory of probable cause… Test the theory to determine cause (e.g., check physical connections before replacing components)."
These excerpts highlight that checking physical connections and cable condition is the first step when LEDs indicate potential issues, especially before assuming hardware failure or specification limits are exceeded.
Additional Reasoning:
LED Behavior: Flashing green and orange LEDs vary by NIC manufacturer, but per the study guide, green flashing often means activity, and orange flashing could signal errors or a speed mismatch. This suggests a link is established but unstable, pointing to cabling issues.
Cable Length: At 275ft, the run is well under 328ft, ruling out immediate need for a hub or fiber upgrade.
Common Issues: Loose RJ45 connectors, pinched cables (exceeding bend radius), or physical damage are frequent causes of intermittent connectivity, easily checked first.
Alternatives: Installing a hub (B) or replacing the cable (C, D) assumes a specific failure without evidence, violating CompTIA’s step-by-step approach.
[References:, The Official CompTIA A+ Core 1 Study Guide (220-1101):, Section 2.6: "Given a scenario, install and configure basic wired/wireless networks" (cable specs and limits)., Section 5.4: "Given a scenario, troubleshoot wired and wireless network problems" (diagnosing connectivity and LED issues)., CompTIA A+ Core 1 (220-1101) Exam Objectives:, Objective 2.6: Understand networking hardware and cable specifications., Objective 5.4: Troubleshoot network connectivity, starting with physical layer checks., , , ]
