IIA Updated IIA-CIA-Part2 Exam Questions and Answers by ismaeel

Benchmarking in internal auditing involves comparing the performance or practices of the audited entity against a standard or best practice, which often involves using information from other organizations or sources as a reference. This process helps identify areas for improvement and set performance targets. Thus, comparing the collected information with similar information from another source is the correct definition of benchmarking.

The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) Practice Guide: Internal Audit and Organizational Performance

IIA Standard 1220 - Due Professional Care

According to the IIA Standards, particularly in the context of risk management consulting, internal audit activities may provide risk management consulting services under specific conditions. These conditions include:

There is a clear strategy and timeline to migrate risk management responsibility back to management.This condition ensures that the internal audit's involvement in risk management is temporary and transitional, emphasizing the principle that management retains ultimate responsibility for risk management.

The nature of services provided to the organization is documented in the internal audit charter.This condition ensures transparency and clarity about the internal audit's role in risk management, as outlined in the internal audit charter. This documentation is essential for defining the scope and limitations of the internal audit's consulting role.

In contrast, options 2 and 3 are inappropriate under the Standards:

The internal audit activity has the final approval on any risk management decisions (Option 2): This would compromise the independence and objectivity of the internal audit function, as internal auditors should not make management decisions.

The internal audit activity gives objective assurance on all parts of the risk management framework for which it is responsible (Option 3): This creates a conflict of interest because internal auditors cannot objectively audit areas where they have direct responsibility.

IIA References:

IIA Standard 2050: Coordination and Reliance emphasizes that internal audit should not assume management responsibilities, including final risk management decisions, to maintain objectivity and independence.

IIA Standard 1000: Purpose, Authority, and Responsibility and related guidance stress the importance of documenting the internal audit’s role in the audit charter, especially when the internal audit is involved in consulting activities like risk management.

An internal control questionnaire (ICQ) is a tool used by auditors to gather detailed information about the internal control system of an audited area. The primary purpose of an ICQ is to identify and assess risks that could prevent the area from achieving its objectives. By systematically covering various control points, the questionnaire helps the auditor evaluate the adequacy and effectiveness of controls in place and identify areas where controls may be lacking or need improvement.

The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) - Practice Guide: Internal Control Questionnaire

The most effective way to identify the HR department's risks and controls, especially after recent process changes, is to discuss the department's present strategies and objectives with the head of the HR department. This approach allows the auditor to gain current and relevant insights directly from the person most knowledgeable about the department's current operations, risks, and controls. It ensures that the auditor understands the current environment, any new challenges, and the specific controls in place to mitigate risks. This method is more comprehensive and current compared to reviewing past reports or generalized organizational frameworks, which might not reflect recent changes accurately.

The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) Standard 2010 – Planning: "The chief audit executive must establish risk-based plans to determine the priorities of the internal audit activity, consistent with the organization’s goals."

IIA Practice Guide on "Engaging with Stakeholders"