Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation From Exact Extract:
Carbolic acid corrosion (phenol corrosion) is described in API RP 571 as a process-specific corrosion mechanism that may not produce distinct or easily detectable wall-loss patterns using conventional NDE methods.
API RP 571 emphasizes that confirmation of carbolic acid corrosion often requires:
Chemical identification of corrosion products
Metallurgical examination
Verification of acid presence and metal interaction
A boat sample (also known as a coupon or scoop sample) removed from the affected area and analyzed in a laboratory allows:
Identification of corrosion morphology
Chemical analysis of deposits
Confirmation of phenol-related attack
Why the other options are incorrect:
UT and RT detect wall loss but cannot identify the corrosion mechanism.
Acoustic emission detects active cracking, not specific corrosion chemistry.
Angle beam UT is for crack detection, not corrosion identification.
Therefore, laboratory analysis of a removed sample is the most useful method.
Referenced Documents (Study Basis):
API RP 571 – Section on Organic Acid Corrosion (Phenols)
API Corrosion Failure Analysis Study Guide
======================