SAVE International Updated VMA Exam Questions and Answers by patricia

The Value Methodology (VM) Job Plan, as outlined in the VMF 1 course and SAVE International’s Value Methodology Standard, consists of six phases, one of which is the Evaluation Phase, where the VM team selects viable ideas. In the Evaluation Phase, the team assesses ideas generated during the Creative Phase to determine their feasibility, cost impact, and alignment with project goals. According to the VMF 1 Core Competency #3 (Value Methodology Job Plan), the Evaluation Phase involves “evaluating the ideas for their potential to improve value, using criteria such as cost savings, performance, quality, and feasibility, to select the most viable alternatives for further development.” Tools like weighted evaluation matrices may be used to rank ideas systematically.

Option A (Function Analysis) is incorrect because this phase focuses on identifying and analyzing functions, not selecting ideas.

Option B (Presentation) is incorrect because this phase involves communicating recommendations to stakeholders, after ideas have already been selected and developed.

Option C (Evaluation) is correct, as it is the phase where the VM team filters and selects viable ideas based on defined criteria.

Option D (Development) is incorrect because this phase involves refining selected ideas into actionable proposals, which happens after the Evaluation Phase.

In the context of Value Methodology, cost analysis often involves financial concepts to evaluate the economic impact of alternatives, including understanding the time value of money. The VMF 1 course, under Core Competency #4 (Cost Analysis), includes basic financial metrics relevant to value studies, such as discounting cash flows to assess long-term value. The nominal rate of increase in the value of money over time, after subtracting for inflation, refers to thereal discount rate. In financial terms, as per standard economic principles taught in VMF 1, the discount rate is the rate used to discount future cash flows to their present value, and thereal discount rateis the nominal discount rate adjusted for inflation (i.e., real discount rate = nominal discount rate − inflation rate). This measures the true increase in the value of money over time, excluding inflationary effects.

Option A (Simple Payback or Breakeven Point) is incorrect because payback measures the time required to recover an investment, not the rate of increase in money’s value.

Option B (Return on Investment or ROI) is incorrect because ROI measures the profitability of an investment as a percentage, not the rate of increase in money’s value over time.

Option C (Discount Rate) is correct because the real discount rate, after subtracting inflation, defines the nominal rate of increase in the value of money over time, as used in financial analyses within VM studies.

Option D (Present Worth or Net Present Value) is incorrect because NPV is the result of discounting future cash flows to their present value using a discount rate, not the rate itself.

Value Methodology (VM), as defined by SAVE International in the Value Methodology Fundamentals 1 (VMF 1) course, is a systematic, step-by-step approach to improve the value of a project, product, or process by optimizing the function-to-cost ratio. According to SAVE International’s Value Methodology Standard, VM is described as “a systematic and structured approach for improving projects, products, and processes… to achieve the optimum balance between function, performance, quality, safety, and cost.” The VM Job Plan, a core component of VM, involves a step-by-step process (six phases: Information, Function Analysis, Creative, Evaluation, Development, and Presentation) that can be likened to a design review because it evaluates and enhances the design or process to improve value.

Option A (suggestion program) is incorrect because VM is not merely about collecting suggestions; it is a structured methodology with defined phases and tools like function analysis.

Option B (cost reduction exercise) is incorrect because VM focuses on improving value, not just reducing costs—cost reduction may occur, but only if it does not compromise essential functions.

Option C (step-by-step design review) aligns with VM’s systematic nature, as the Job Plan reviews and improves designs or processes through structured phases, making it the best fit.

Option D (eight-phase process) is incorrect because the VM Job Plan has six phases, not eight, as established in SAVE International’s standards.